• 2 Posts
  • 559 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 10th, 2023

help-circle




  • You’re using the “no true scotsman” defence right now. There is no other country comparable to the size of Canada in the world other than Russia, so does that mean we can only look at them for policy?

    “I don’t know about this place so I’m not going to be able to even consider it’s policies” - That’s an ignorance argument.

    Where’s your proof that any of the policies you’re suggesting will work? Do you have a single example of them working elsewhere?


  • This is just objectively false.

    Japan didn’t have single family zoning, anyone could build dense housing anywhere residential in any of the major cities and they absolutely did, and yet it was never affordable. They have massively walkable cities, with great public transportation, and yet… not affordable unless you want to live in a 100 square foot closet that most north Americans couldn’t even fit through the door on.

    A bunch of US cities have no zoning and are still not affordable.

    Zoning is a slight bottleneck, but it’s not even close to the core problem.

    I’m not saying don’t change the zoning, go ahead, but expecting things to become affordable in a few years is an absolute pipe dream.

    BC just did it, and developers are just shit talking the policy saying it doesn’t change anything.











  • Social housing can never be the true solution. The government doesn’t have enough money to make it have an impact. Even in cities in Europe that have 30-40% social housing, they are still having housing crisis situations where people can’t move, people wait years to affordable units, and private housing is still astronomically expensive.

    There is a proper fix, but it destroys almost all of the equity in the existing housing market which means voters will never go for it. Far too many people still own houses and would lose hundreds of thousands or even millions.

    So instead we get this pandering shit, and prices will continue to rise for the next few decades.